That is an version of The Atlantic Every day, a publication that guides you thru the largest tales of the day, helps you uncover new concepts, and recommends the most effective in tradition. Join it right here.
Rock and roll is filled with legends who ought to retire. However some bands know get again onstage with out making fools of themselves—or of their followers.
First, listed here are three Sunday reads from The Atlantic:
Hey, Cleveland
Typically I write one thing that wants a wee little bit of qualification. (Translation: I’m going to rationalize breaking considered one of my very own guidelines.) Final 12 months, I applauded rock artists who select to age gracefully, largely by exiting the stage. I deplored the acts who have been attempting to recapture their youthful days whereas cynically vacuuming their followers’ pockets.
In that dialogue, I quoted the critic John Strausbaugh, whose 2001 ebook, Rock Til You Drop, is filled with liquid-nitrogen zingers so exact and stinging that I want I’d written them. Strausbaugh rightly says that rock and roll needs to be music by the younger, for the younger, and he rails towards the sham of what he calls “colostomy rock”—older individuals mugging their manner by means of songs about intercourse and medicines and riot:
Rock merely shouldn’t be performed by fifty-five-year-old males with triple chins sporting unhealthy wighats. Its prime viewers shouldn’t be middle-aged, balding, jelly-bellied dads who’ve introduced alongside their wives and youngsters … Rock‘n’roll isn’t household leisure.
That’s rattling proper, John, and I couldn’t agree extra.
So what, precisely, was I doing earlier this month on a quaint little road in a seaside city in Rhode Island, getting patted down by safety for a present by the Tubes, a band recognized for his or her decadent stage exhibits and whose largest hits have been from the Nineteen Seventies and ’80s? I final noticed the Tubes about 40 years in the past, when the band was enjoying the Boston faculty circuit. What the hell was I doing right here? Extra to the purpose, what the hell have been they doing right here?
For those who’re not acquainted with the Tubes, maybe I may give you a way of their, ah, aesthetic from a few of their songs, together with odes to loving relationships similar to “Don’t Contact Me There” and “Mondo Bondage,” in addition to their ever-popular investigation of youthful anxieties, “White Punks on Dope.” Within the ’80s, their two largest hits have been “Speak to Ya Later,” about exasperation with a one-night stand who gained’t go away the following day, and “She’s a Magnificence,” a large hit on the charts and on MTV in 1983, whose lyrics principally describe the foundations for what have been as soon as known as rap cubicles, cubicles in city red-light districts that have been the pre-internet equal of cam websites. (“You’ll be able to say / Something you want / However you’ll be able to’t contact the merchandise.”)
That is the sort of music that made Soviet commissars assume the West was doomed to fall.
However it’s additionally the sort of music that appears fairly unusual when carried out by males of a sure age. I imply, who needs to see a shirtless previous coot come out onstage in leather-based pants and a bondage masks?
Nicely, because it seems, I do. And so did my spouse, who isn’t solely my age but in addition noticed the Tubes years in the past and jumped on the likelihood to see them once more.
The Tubes have the one high quality that so many older bands lack: self-awareness. When the lead singer, Price Waybill, took the stage on the Greenwich Odeum that night time, he chuckled and famous that this was a return engagement, and that everybody was a 12 months older now. “Which implies,” he added, “I’m, like, fuckin’ 100 now.” (He’s truly 73; the unique band members Roger Steen and Prairie Prince are 74 and 73, respectively.)
The remainder of the night was not a reenactment of the previous days, however a sort of comfortable postcard from the early ’80s. This understanding however joyful wink makes all of the distinction when strolling the wonderful line, because the rock mockumentary This Is Spinal Faucet put it, “between intelligent and silly.” The band will get it, and so does the viewers: We’re all older now, and we’re not kidding anybody, however we are able to nonetheless sing together with songs that will probably shock our kids.
The proper venue is the important thing to having fun with this sort of music with out feeling like an fool. The Greenwich Odeum is a small theater in a city of roughly 13,000 people who seats slightly below 500—hardly the sort of area that bands just like the Tubes as soon as crammed. I puzzled how all of us got here to be singing alongside to “Sushi Woman”—don’t ask—in a former vaudeville theater inbuilt 1926, so I known as the Odeum a couple of weeks after the present and chatted with Rachel Kinnevy-Fitzpatrick, who handles artist relations, and the final supervisor, Amanda Ronchi.
The Odeum, they instructed me, had fallen into disuse, nevertheless it reemerged in 2013 with the assistance of patrons and sponsors; it’s now a music and comedy spot. However it’s hardly a dusty previous dive: Its roster consists of Amy Grant, Al Di Meola, an ABBA tribute band, and Al Stewart and his terrific younger colleagues, the Empty Pockets, whom I’ve seen twice there. The home can be holding a Celtic Christmas celebration and internet hosting Lez Zeppelin, an all-female Zep tribute band (though not on the similar time).
When bands are younger and hungry, they play the massive rooms and go the place the bus takes them. Once they get a bit older, they don’t wish to be shoved onstage and compelled to yell, “Hey, Cleveland!” (Likewise, a lot of their followers are too previous to place up with sitting within the nosebleed seats at some decaying native civic area.) The Odeum tries to create a extra intimate surroundings for the artists, and it appears to work: I used to be shocked to be standing within the foyer—which has the comforting atmosphere of an previous movie show—when Waybill and Steen got here out after the present, sat at a desk, and signed autographs and chitchatted with followers, together with me.
A smaller venue such because the Odeum (supported by each ticket gross sales and patrons and sponsors) additionally signifies that the band, and the followers, can overlook about attempting to re-create their days of fist-pumping area glory. None of us, onstage or off, appeared up for that sort of creepy nostalgia. As Rachel stated concerning the venue’s older acts, nobody has to reside prior to now; the Odeum thinks it’s “okay to remain current.”
Talking of age, I famous that the gang on the practically sold-out present was nearly solely over 40, an remark confirmed by the theater’s administration. The present was not an intergenerational second with the children and grandkids, the place the creaky Boomers launched the youngs to their prehistoric rock idols. (That’s what Rolling Stones concert events are for.) Maybe it sounds odd to name a rock live performance a protected area, however I felt extra comfy shouting lyrics similar to “Spent my money on each excessive I may discover” in a crowd of individuals near my very own age than I may need whereas getting the stink eye from somebody’s appalled teenager.
Again within the day, the Tubes placed on a blinding present, with particular results, scantily clad dancing women, and a number of costume adjustments. All of that’s over. Now solely Waybill adjustments garments, and the one sultry woman onstage is dressed as a nurse—cue the Viagra jokes from the viewers—as an alternative of a kick-line dancer. (She’s additionally not a groupie or employed additional; she’s Waybill’s spouse, Elizabeth.)
Some issues, even in the midst of a rock live performance, make extra sense while you’re older. After Waybill reworked into considered one of his onstage alter egos, the dissolute glam rocker Quay Lewd—drug humor from the ’70s, youngsters—he appeared over on the character’s trademark 18-inch-heel boots mendacity onstage close by. Apparently, he’d worn them at a present in Philadelphia the night time earlier than, they usually’d damage like hell; there was even some concern about whether or not he’d be in form for the present in Rhode Island. So this night time, he simply checked out them and shook his head: Nah.
The gang laughed. We get it.
Tonight, keep current, and rejoice with the music that strikes you. Completely satisfied New 12 months. See you in 2024.
Associated:
Essay
The Weird Tragedy of Youngsters’s Films
By Kelly Conaboy
A couple of weeks in the past, I got here throughout a GIF from the 1994 movie The Lion King that made me weep. It exhibits the lion cub Simba moments after he discovers the lifeless physique of his father, Mufasa; he nuzzles below Mufasa’s limp arm after which lies down beside him. I used to be instantly distraught at that scene, and my recollections of those that comply with: Simba pawing at his lifeless father’s face, Simba pleading with him to “stand up.”
That scene lives in my ideas with a couple of comparable ones: the infant elephant Dumbo cradled in his abused mother’s trunk as she’s trapped behind bars; Ellie, the beloved spouse in Up, grieving a miscarriage and ultimately passing away inside the first 5 minutes of the movie; Bambi, the younger deer, wandering across the snowy forest in search of his mom, who has simply been shot lifeless. Once they pop up in my thoughts, I’m all the time left with the identical thought: Why are so many youngsters’ motion pictures so unhappy, and the way does that disappointment have an effect on the children they’re supposed to entertain?
Tradition Break
/media/img/posts/2023/12/books_12_29/original.gif)
Learn. Try considered one of The Atlantic’s 10 favourite books of 2023.
Hear. Don’t purchase that new sweater till you’ve heard what Atlantic workers author Amanda Mull has to say concerning the cratering high quality of knitwear on this episode of Radio Atlantic.
Picture Album
Households and buddies at play, expressions of affection and compassion, volunteers at work, and extra in our editor’s choice of hopeful photographs from 2023.
Stephanie Bai contributed to this text.
Whenever you purchase a ebook utilizing a hyperlink on this publication, we obtain a fee. Thanks for supporting The Atlantic.
